Thinking Differently: Deciding Which Hand to Follow
1. Create an Effect:
Deodorant manufacturers believed that a body spray
would never succeed in the U.S. because the category simply didn't exist.
But they were just looking at one hand. They failed to imagine what might be
in the other hand and instead stuck to the conventional wisdom.
2. Follow the other hand:
Unilever, the manufacturer of AXE, looked at
the other hand and challenged this assumption. They challenged the view that
the main reason people buy deodorants is to avoid sweat and smell. AXE
accepted that (a) the fact that no one had done a body spray in the U.S. did
not mean it was impossible and that (b) guys don't care how they smell when
with other guys, but with girls it's a different story. So, (c), Unilever
decided to position the body sprays to guys 18-24 as a way of helping them
"get the girl."
3. Develop the method:
Try thinking what the process would be if you
followed the new solutions or ideas. What could you accomplish if you chose
to ignore those voices that said, "it can't be done?" and instead thought,
"What if it could be done?"
4. Begin with a great performance:
AXE tested provocative banner
advertising such as showing cheerleaders running after football players
trying to pull their pants down. One million visitors clicked on the ad,
visited the site and stayed—on average—more than 5 minutes. This was a month
before the product was even in the stores. Unilever also placed AXE where
the boys shopped in the store: the electronic, music, and auto departments of Wal-Mart and other retail distributors.
5. Achieving the effect:
Following the other hand generates new ideas and
offers great success, and the rewards go to those who perform first. AXE was
one of the most successful product launches in early 2000. The product line
was expanded to more than 16 similar body sprays from "Apollo" to "Voodoo."
Within two years. Old Spice and Tag introduced their own body sprays,
closely mimicking AXE's original positioning. AXE was the first to challenge
the assumption and the others have been playing catch-up even since.
Adapted from Follow the Other Hand by Andy Cohen, St. Martin's Press
November 2006